Updated November 2026. Reviewed by Richard W. Taylor.
You can file a diminished value claim in Delaware against the at-fault driver’s insurance company. Diminished value is the resale value your car loses because it now has an accident history, even after quality repairs. Delaware measures damage to a car as the difference between its value just before the accident and its value just after, which is the basis for a diminished value claim. Here is how a diminished value claim in Delaware works, the deadline, and how to file one.
Key takeaways
- Delaware diminished value claims go against the at-fault driver’s insurance company.
- The Delaware Supreme Court measures damage to a car as its value just before the accident minus its value just after (Teitsworth v. Kempski, 1956).
- Your own collision coverage does not pay diminished value under standard repair or replace wording (O’Brien v. Progressive Northern, 2001).
- You have only 2 years to sue for damage to your car.
- The Justice of the Peace Court hears claims up to $25,000, and you do not need a lawyer there.
Can you file a diminished value claim in Delaware?
Yes, against the driver who caused the accident. In Teitsworth v. Kempski (1956), the Delaware Supreme Court restated the long-standing rule that damage to a car is the difference between its value immediately before the accident and its value immediately after. A diminished value claim documents the part of that difference the repairs do not restore. Delaware appellate courts have not issued a recent opinion focused on diminished value after repairs, so a well-documented appraisal matters.
Your own policy is different. In O’Brien v. Progressive Northern Insurance Co. (2001), the Delaware Supreme Court held that standard repair or replace policy language does not cover diminished value. Plan to file against the at-fault driver’s insurer.
Delaware diminished value claims at a glance
| Item | Delaware |
|---|---|
| Claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer | Yes, third-party claim |
| How damage is measured | Value before minus value after (Teitsworth, 1956) |
| Claim under your own collision policy | No under standard wording (O’Brien, 2001) |
| Deadline to sue for damage to your car | 2 years, 10 Del. C. 8107 |
| Justice of the Peace Court limit | $25,000, 10 Del. C. 9301 |
How to file a diminished value claim in Delaware
- Finish the repairs and keep the final repair bill, since the claim is based on it.
- Get the at-fault driver’s claim details: the insurer, the claim number and the adjuster.
- Get an independent appraisal. A documented appraisal shows your car’s value before and after, based on the repair bill, the actual damage and current retail market data for comparable cars with a clean history.
- Send a written demand with the appraisal to the at-fault driver’s insurer, and keep copies.
- Act within 2 years. If the claim does not settle, the Delaware Justice of the Peace Court hears claims up to $25,000.
DVAC provides the appraisal report, the demand letter, claim strategy and guidance through resolution. You communicate with the insurance company directly, and we advise you on what to say and how to respond.
What if the Delaware insurer refuses to pay?
Ask the adjuster to explain the decision in writing and to respond to the figures in your appraisal. If the claim still does not settle, the Delaware Justice of the Peace Court hears property damage claims up to $25,000, and you are not required to have a lawyer. Either side can appeal to the Court of Common Pleas within 15 days for a new trial. Watch the deadline: Delaware allows only 2 years from the accident to sue for damage to your car. For larger claims or legal questions, talk to a Delaware attorney. If your car was totaled instead, see our Delaware total loss guide.
Delaware diminished value case studies
See how DVAC helped document $7,025 of diminished value in Delaware.
Delaware diminished value questions
Is Delaware a diminished value state?
Yes, for third-party claims against the at-fault driver’s insurer, based on Delaware’s before and after value rule.
How long do I have to file a diminished value claim in Delaware?
2 years to sue for injury to personal property under 10 Del. C. 8107.
Does my own insurance pay diminished value in Delaware?
Not under standard repair or replace collision wording (O’Brien v. Progressive Northern, 2001).
What is the small claims limit in Delaware?
The Justice of the Peace Court hears claims up to $25,000.
Sources
- Teitsworth v. Kempski, 127 A.2d 237 (Del. 1956) (CourtListener).
- O’Brien v. Progressive Northern Insurance Co., 785 A.2d 281 (Del. 2001) (CourtListener).
- 10 Del. C. 8107, two years for injury to personal property (Delaware Code).
- 10 Del. C. 9301, Justice of the Peace Court civil jurisdiction ($25,000) (Delaware Code).
- Delaware Courts, Justice of the Peace Court FAQs.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Diminished value rules can change and depend on the facts of your claim, so confirm current requirements with your state insurance department or an attorney.







